FALSE ABROGATION CLAIM

 

According to some label Muslim or their corrupted so-called scholar, they believe Al-Quran has verses which are abrogated / invalidated. But to me it is nothing but a FALSE manmade theory and because of that they don’t know exactly how many verses were abrogated?

 

Such belief may become a point of confusion sometimes, specially when some abrogated verses deals with life and death matters , such as most so-called scholars believe that the stoning punishment of adultery for (married persons), which was once in the Qur'an, has been abrogated from recitation, or eaten by goat, but still remains in effect in the Sharia Law.

 

However this concept was originally invented by so-called scholars as a result of their poor understanding of the Quran, yet it has been widely exploited by anti-Quranic writers to tarnish the perfection and divinity of the book.

 

Anyway such corrupters has invented the greatest lie about the Quran, claiming that there are verses in the Quran that abrogate and invalidate other verses They give reference of two verse [2:106 & 16:101] which insha-Allah I will discuses on this article but before that one need ponder on all other relevant verses .

 

THE VERSE THAT RELATED TO THE SUBJECT

[please note all translation is simply understanding of the translator so it is not Allah's Al-Quran ]

 

The Quran 10 :64

For them are Glad Tidings, in the life of the Present and in the Hereafter: no change can there be in the Words of Allah. This is indeed the supreme Felicity.

 

The Quran 11:1

Alif. Lam. Ra. (This is) a Scripture the revelations whereof are perfected and then expounded. (It cometh) from One Wise, Aware,

 

The Quran 43 : 48

We showed them Sign after Sign, each grater then its fellow, and We seized them with Punishment, in order that they might turn (to Us).

 

The Quran 45:29

This Our Record speaks about you with truth: for We were wont to put on NASTANSIKH (record) all that ye did

 

The Quran 7:154

When the anger of Moses was appeased he took up the Tablets: in the writing thereon was Guidance and Mercy for such as fear their Lord. [NUSKHATIHA]

 

The Quran 22:52

Never did We send an messenger or a prophet before thee but when he framed a desire, Satan threw some (vanity) into his desire: but Allah will YANSAKH (cancel) anything (vain) that Satan throws in, and Allah will confirm (and establish) His Signs: for Allah is full of knowledge and wisdom:

 

The Quran 22: 53

That He may make the suggestions thrown in by Satan, but a trial for those in whose hearts is a disease and who are hardened of heart: verily the wrongdoers are in a schism far (from the Truth):

 

The Quran 6:112

Likewise did We make for every Messenger an enemy,- evil ones among men and jinns, inspiring each other with flowery discourses by way of deception. If thy Lord had so planned, they would not have done it: so leave them and their inventions alone.

 

The Quran 17:88

Say: "If the whole of mankind and jinns were to gather together to produce the like of this Qur'an, they could not produce the like thereof, even if they backed up each other with help and support.


 

TWO VERSES WHICH BEEN VICTIM OF MISTRANSLATION BY THEM 

 

The Quran 2:106 

Whatever  We cancel from/of a sign/ayat

Or [We] cause it to be forgotten

We bring better than it

Or similar (to) it.

Do not you know that Allah over

Every thing (is) All-Powerful?

 

The Quran :16:101 

And when We substitute/change a Verse PLACE a Verse,

and Allah (is) most knowing of what He sends down

they say, "Only you an inventor."

Nay, most of them (do) not know.

 

LETS TRY TO UNDERTAND THEM TWO VERSE

 

VERSE 2:106 

The word [AYAT ] it not necessarily just mean revelation / verses of AQ but according to the Quran it has several other meaning such as: 17:101=MIRACLE / 19:10 =SIGN / 25:37 =EXAMPLE  

 

Therefore I believe the term "Ayat" mention in this particular verse is talking about that portion that inserted by Satan as mention on [22:52] And that is what Allah cancel and made it forgotten. However even if I take it as "miracle, example or sign" then verse [43 : 48] does indicate Allah did showed people sign after sign, each greater other. And when I take it's talking about VERSE /AYAT  still it does NOT prove their false claim that Allah has abrogate HIS own verse / command / law [simple such understanding create problem that Allah unable to determined what to do, therefore keep change his plan same as  human ]  
 

[ 22:52] clearly indicate that there has never been any messenger or a prophet that SATAN did not threw some (vanity) into his desire: but Allah will [YANSAKH=Cancel] anything that Satan throws in, and Allah will confirm/ Establish HIS Verse/Ayat. So it is simply whenever SATAN try to insert something within the VERSE of Allah [even today it could be indicating to them  translation/ interpretation /  Hadith / Bible / Masnah & other manmade books ] to confuse  believers, Therefore Allah make sure that vain saying get cancel and get forgotten [and that's why we don't find many hafiz have memorised them manmade books] so that Allah’s reinstate the original verse/ ayat will always be dominated & established.  

 

VERSE 16:101 

This verse is very clear how can someone get confused ?  

They are trying to misinterpret this verse by saying CHANGE of VERSE but in the verse [16:101] we see it is NOT change of verse but the change of PLACE. Therefore Allah simply saying here" HE change a place of verse to another "and for that reason we see same verse repeat in deferent chapter. So the simple translation is “ And when We put a revelation in place of revelation, - and Allah knoweth best what He revealeth - they say: Lo! thou art but inventing. Most of them know not “

 

CONCLUSION

 

Them corrupters misinterpret them verses two verse only the sake of their manmade hadith which invented by their gurus and attributed to beloved prophet Muhammed [s]  in order to gain validity. The other reason for  supporting this false abrogation theory is that whenever they find themselves in sticky situation on debate with none Muslim specially when none muslim use their manmade hadith and attack them back then the easy way out is by saying it is abrogated and to validate their concept they used them two verses  [2:106 / Q16;101]


 

Other possible reason could be that, because there is unlimited contradiction within their manmade Hadith books.  So if they can somehow show Al-Quran also contain same contradictory or abrogation method, then no one will have any problem if one hadith abrogate other since they need to keep modify it to fit their notion or contradiction. Yet they forget Al-Quran CONTAINS NO CONTRADICTIONS regardless they like it or not. 

 

In light of above information , if someone still wish to continue follow blindly with such false dangerous believe, without true investigation on this issue, then he/she must also understand that, this kind of belief does lead to, some serous question on Allah (swt) & the Quran itself. All of them so-called scholar’s claims of abrogation verses, are based upon less pondering on the Quran or defending the so-called Hadith

 

Also remember Allah do not need to change HIS way / sunnatulah, therefore this term NANSAKH=CANCEL mention on the verse 2:106 is NOT taking anything that Allah change HIS law or abrogate any command due to Allah not knowing the future. But it was simply mention whatever Satan inserted that portion been cancel and made it fully FORGOTTEN.

if one verses is abrogated by another verse then why that abrogated verse still in Al-Quran, and how is it forgotten if it is still in Al-Quran ?

And when Allah say it been replace with similar or better it does NOT mean Allah change HIS own word and replace it into similar or better but it rather mean whatever the effect that made by that false insertion Allah replace that with ether similar or good.My firm belief that no verses of Al-Quarn has been abrogated ever Nor it has no validity, neither Allah need to change HIS mind due to any situation which HE unaware off [Allah knows best].