REFUTING SOME SUNNI’S ASSUMPTION 

  

Here are just few of the popular question which been asked by Hadith follower, whenever I encounter them. Please note to save time & space I have used AQ in sort of “Al-Quran “ and  AH in-sort of “AHadith.

 

SUNNI

How do you pray salah using al-Quran only, because AQ does not give any format And we find that it in hadith ?

 

MY REPLY

As-Salah and all other ritual act of Islam was practiced well before prophet Muhammad [s] and prophet Mohammed was commended to follow the Millat-e-Ibraheem [religion of prophet Ibraheem [s] therefore the format of As-Salah was all ready there in the time of prophet Muhammad [s]. Moreover AQ has full detail of it’s  format anyway. But the problem is you are asking AQ to validate your own homemade format, which inverted by your hadith books and the funniest thing is, you need thousand of hadith to established two rakat of salah format, while AQ simply establishes it by using just one verses [10:26] by simply mentioning standing bowing & prostration and that is the original format of As-Salah, yet you have added so many other stuff to it  and now you wanted  AQ  to support your style, while  you forget it is you who need to adjust with Al-Quran, its is not the other way round.

 

SUNNI

Allah mention several time in AQ to obey Allah, obey  messenger, therefore obey messenger meaning following his hadith & sunnah, Since you don’t do follow hadith, so in realty you are rejecting the AQ too ?

 

MY REPLY

Yes Allah  did mention so many time, but did HE ever  mention just even once, for us to follow Muhammad [s] by name, or is there any single verse which say “obey Allah & obey prophet Mohammed ”  if not then is there no reason behind it ?

 

Of-course, this is why it’s always say obey MESSENGER meaning the message, also don’t forget sometime this term “messenger” is indicating toward angel messenger who bought down AQ. Therefore Prophet Mohammed had to also obey Allah and obey the messenger by believing in Allah and believing His angel messenger and for us, we need to obey Allah meaning believing Allah and obey messenger meaning believing the message what prophet Muhammad [s] conveyed which was only AQ  

 

SUNNI

OK but we believe hadith explain AQ and we received AQ same way as we received AH, therefore why you deny ahadith ?

 

MY REPLY

Well I am not only one who rejecting hadith, in-fact all of your famous Imam such as Imam Buhkary. Imam Muslim, Imam Thirmizi all of them nearly rejected  99.% of the hadith which they collected, then what’s wrong if I reject 100%, yet you guys reject all Shia hadith while Shia reject all of your hadith, yet you complain I reject both, specially when I find every  single hadith is recorded against the method of AQ, because AQ indicate any single witness on important issue is not valid [2:282], while every single hadith is recorded with single chain of narration somewhere along the line.

 

Also you believe hadith explain AQ, yet you forget the whole entire hadith science don’t even manage to cover one third of the Quran as an explanation, Yet Allah mention AQ explain itself, so why does the explanation need to be further explained ?

 

You also claim AQ came down the same way as AH well you better get your facts right, because I don’t find any [in-fact probably none ] 7-9 year old Muslim child who know any Ahadith by their heart, while most them know at-least few verses of AQ. Also how many adult Muslim really knows any Ahadith compare to they know AQ. Therefore the fact is AQ did not come the same way as you trying to assume.

 

SUNNI

Our scholar say Ahdith-e Qudsi indirect word / revelation  of Allah therefore anyone denying that is not Muslim, so do you also reject hadith -e- Qudsi too ?

 

MY REPLY

First of All how did your scholar identify which one is Hadith-e-Qudsi and what is not, also  who told them there is such thing as hadith-e-Qudsi and is it mention anywhere  in AQ ?

 

Or is it more likely your scholar inventing it, to secure their own position, because some Shia also claim some extra revelation came down directly to Ali and they only invented this to make Ali as a supreme person /leader .

 

Anyway I don’t care if your scholar label me whatever they like, Yet I wonder who given them such authority to say who is Muslim and who is not. They forget All prophets / messengers  try to make  none believer to Muslim, while them so-called  scholar is busy how to make Muslim to none-Muslim by issuing such baseless fatwa of theirs.

 

SUNNI

Did you not read 59:7 which say  “Take whatever prophet give and abstain from whatever he told you to abstain ”  Therefore this also validate his saying and hadith sunnah, So when you don’t follow hadith are you not going against that verses of Allah ?

 

MY REPLY

Why are you using small portion of that verses out of context or do you just like to pick & chose whatever suits your needs, Why don’t you look at the whole verses and see what is taking about?

 

Because to me it is describing a situation of the war and it taking about booty, therefore why are you concocting small portion of that verses and making it as general rule ?

 

CONCLUSION

 

Up to now I have not find any Sunni’s follower  or their scholar welling to have proper intellectual One to One debate with term and condition. 

For some reason they are too scared to face the truth, however if anyone wish to arrange any debate and happily accept the below mention rule, then please do contact me and Insha-Allah we will see how long does the falsehood last ?

 

 

TERM AND CONDITION

 

[1] The term & condition needs to be agreed by both candidates before proceeding, if they feel any amendment needed, then they should do well before the debate.

 

[2] Must take oath on the topic according the verse 3:61 openly and publicly before starting the debate.  


[3] Each candidate must prove his case from Arabic Quran  And all relevant evidence must be provided from the Arabic Quran only.

[4] All translation or interpretation of any particular word must fit with every single verses where its  appears in AQ, while the sentence should make sense too, it should not contradict with any other verse. 

[5] The debate must be preside by neutral person who is not belong to any candidate groups /sect and the closing statement must be provide by the president in good faith without taking any side.

 

[6] Total time limit must declare before start of the debate & and the president must strictly maintain the time limit, and must be fair & equal to both candidate

 

[7] Both candidate must avoid any abusive behaviour or criticizing, insulting during the debate each other directly or indirectly.

 

HERE IS THE SAMPLE OF THE OATH WHICH NEED TO BE AGREED BY BOTH CANDIDATE BEFORE ANY DEBATE


 

MY DECLARATION

I DECLARE ACCORDING TO VERSE 3:61 WHAT MENTION ON BELOW MAY ALLAH CURSE ON THE LIAR


THE QURAN IS COMPLETE, FULLY DETAIL & SOLELY ENOUGH AS GUIDANCE. AND  SO-CALLED HADITH ARE  FALSE & MANMADE [save any portion which contain verses or support any verse ]


SUNNI DECLARATION

I DECLARE ACCORDING TO VERSE 3:61 WHAT MENTION ON BELOW MAY ALLAH CURSE ON THE LIAR


THE QURAN IS NOT ENOUGH AS GUIDANCE .IT NEED HADITH / SUNNAH WHICH IS THE EXPLANATION OF THE QURAN WITHOUT IT THE QURAN CANNOT BE FOLLOWED CORRECTLY, ALL SAHAHI HADITH IS TRUE SAYING OF PROPHET MUHAMMED [P]

 

ALL HADITH -E- QUDSI ARE  ALSO INDIRECT EXTRA REVELATION FROM ALLAH,ANYONE WHO DENY IT ARE  NOT MUSLIM.

 

 

LASTLY

It is important to see all other article which mention below, to understand more clearly regarding this hadith issue

 

http://thequranthesolution.webs.com/whyalquran.htm

 

http://thequranthesolution.webs.com/whyifollowalqurankitab.htm

 

http://thequranthesolution.webs.com/obeyallahobeymessenger.htm